The holocaust is not an arbitrary but rather an internally coherent construct. Real history and the norman finkelstein controversy. In an iconoclastic and controversial study, norman g. Jul 12, 2000 norman finkelstein has caused a storm on both sides of the atlantic and it is not hard to see why. Finkelstein moves from an interrogation of the place the holocaust has come to occupy in american culture to. How would it change our understanding if the nazi holocaust were not the first but the fourth or fifth in a line of comparable catastrophes. Finkelsteins book is a call for jewish suffering to be seen as. Recalling holocaust fraudsters such as jerzy kosinski and binjamin wilkomirski, as well as the demagogic constructions of writers like daniel goldhagen, finkelstein contends that the main danger posed to the memory of nazisms victims comes from some of the very people who profess most passionately to defend it. Reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering norman g. In 1984 a book by one joan peters was published, from time immemorial.
Jan 08, 2012 alan hart interviews norman finkelstein about israel, zionism and the holocaust industry. Mar 02, 2015 norman finkelstein is a son of jewish survivors who had survived the holocaust. So norman finkelstein has a new book jewlicious the. Longtime propalestinian apologist norman finkelstein seems to have had it with the cult of the international solidarity movement ism and the boycotts, divestment and sanctions bds movement. On the holocaust and its implications 5 governments and political organizations, and many more civilians than soldiers were killed.
Norman finkelstein, son of holocaust survivors, calls netanyahu a maniac. All it is, is an ideological weapon of israel and its supporters to immunize israel and its supporters from criticism. Home world norman finkelstein, son of holocaust survivors. After the lecture, an elderly jewish woman got up and angrily declared to the audience that she was a holocaust survivor and what the zionists were doing to the palestinians was exactly the same as what the germans had done to the jews. Reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering second edition new york.
Jul 20, 20 this is an edited version of the live interview we did with the us academic, author and activist dr norman finkelstein. In his iconoclastic and controversial study, norman g. Jews are immune from any kind of criticism excerpts norman finkelstein american, jew, polemicist on the exclusive claim of suffering. Norman finkelstein, son of holocaust survivors, calls. The holocaust industry is greatly uneven in its valueindeed, i cannot think of another recent work that is both so very good and so very bad. In it, finkelstein discusses how the nazi holocaust was used to service norman finkelstein is the son of two holocaust survivors. The thrust of the argument, about how jews ignored the holocaust and israel until about 1970 and then took them up with a vengeance because it served american imperialist interests, is largely cribbed from a book by novick. Finkelstein moves from an interrogation of the place the holocaust has come to occupy in american culture. The goldhagen thesis and historical truth new york 1998, 91n83, 96n90. A storm has burst out over the holocaust industry, the provocative new book by the left wing new york historian norman finkelstein. Norman finkelstein biography norman gary finkelstein born december 8, 1953 is an american political scientist, activist and author.
On the holocaust and its implications united nations. The american jewish scholar is one of the worlds leading experts on the israelpalestine conflict and the political legacy of the nazi holocaust. These buttons register your public agreement, disagreement, thanks, lol, or troll with the selected comment. Life for jews was a much simpler time, until hitler became germany. Finkelstein should be credited for writing a wellresearched book that can help shut down the holocaust industry when the public becomes aware of its dishonesty and its vulgar exploitation of jewish suffering. Apart from his parents, every member of finkelstein s family, on both sides, was exterminated in the nazi. American jews have exploited and manipulated the suffering in the second world war for their own benefit. Norman finkelsteins the holocaust industry counter.
Norman finkelstein is a son of jewish survivors who had survived the holocaust. The holocaust industry norman finkelstein vostfr nestapaname2. Z magazine the reality of the nazi holocaust remains. This book is both an anatomy and an indictment of the holocaust industry. Norman finkelstein, the jew other jews hate stormfront. The assault on holocaust memory 5 because the shoah is such a significant fact of israeli life and is also subject to manipulation and misuse, many have voiced disquiet over the prominence of the holocaust in the public sphere and, on occasion, have even advocated something like suppression. Reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering london. May 17, 2016 web only features may 17, 2016 norman finkelsteins the holocaust industry and the fight to make all suffering count. Norman gary finkelstein born december 8, 1953 is an american political scientist, activist and author. Home isralicious so norman finkelstein has a new book. Through the innumerable pages of the testimonial writings of those who endured the ghettos and camps of occupied eu. Reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering is a 2000 book by norman finkelstein, in which the author argues that the american jewish establishment exploits the memory of the nazi holocaust for political and financial gain, as well as to further the interests of israel.
Verso, 2000 holocaust guilt we are now all so familiar with holocaust rhetoric from jewish organizations that its characteristic audacity can easily pass unnoticed. Finkelstein, image and reality of the israel palestine. When jews feel and say that germany and those in europe who supported, or at least. Chomsky and finkelstein on joan peters from time immemorial. This is an edited version of the live interview we did with the us academic, author and activist dr norman finkelstein. As norman finkelstein s flight from new york touches down tomorrow morning in london, it lands the brooklynborn writer and holocaust academic in the middle of a major storm. Finkelstein s work provides uncomfortable truths for some when combined with his own unique familial insight into a place in history where many fear to venture. He has had a tense rivalry with his proisrael counterpart, alan dershowitz. Youtube norman finkelstein is no stranger to controversy.
Because the holocaust memorial day has nothing to do with the nazi holocaust. In this part of the interview dr finkelstein explains what happened when a. Jan 01, 2000 the holocaust industry, however, deals with a different subject. And, although the holocaust industry is finkelsteins most frequently cited book in defamatory attempts to cast him as a holocaust denier and a. By the holocaust industry, i mean the main jewish organizations, as well as their academic and media affiliates, which are churning out daily what in my view is a complete.
If someone cares about this quote, try to get the full article in which it appeared, or contact the magazine or norman finkelstein and ask about it. Rosenfeld j ewish literature of the holocaust is animated by the im perative to remember. He is vocal against israels crimes against palestinians, and is strongly opposed to using one of the worst tragedies in history to justify genocide. While some of finkelsteins attacks are unjustified, particularly those against the state of israel and its supporters, his courageous attacks on the financial extortions by groups like the wjc are. United bank of switzerland a merger of major swiss banks from operating in the. A devoted son of holocaust survivors, an ardent critic of israel and us middle east policy, finkelstein has been steadfast at the centre of many intractable controversies, including his denial of tenure at depaul university. Dubbed by novick the sacralization of the holocaust, this mystifications most practices purveyor is. Finkelstein moves from an interrogation of the place the holocaust has come to occupy in american culture to a. The case for norman finkelstein opinion the guardian. He is a graduate of binghamton university and received his ph. Jun 14, 2007 and, although the holocaust industry is finkelstein s most frequently cited book in defamatory attempts to cast him as a holocaust denier and a denier of justice to holocaust survivors, image. Nazi comparisons and antisemitic beliefs combine in a volatile mix. Reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering 2000.
Alan hart interviews norman finkelstein about israel, zionism and the holocaust industry. His primary fields of research are the israelipalestinian conflict and the politics of the holocaust. Finkelstein moves from an interrogation of the place the holocaust has come to occupy in global. Finkelstein is presented as an expert on the holocaust, because he has noted that there are holocaust survivors who do not receive payments, and many of the money intended for holocaust survivors does not end up in the right place. Reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering. No other persecution of the jews equals the extent and brutality of the holocaust, nazi germany. For them to become a protected class, the holocaust, a historical event, had to be turned into the holocaust, a religious one. A storm has burst out over the holocaust industry, the provocative new book by the. Norman finkelstein 1953 is an american political scientist and historian whose work focuses on the history of the palestinians and zionism. Highly recommended to those who value truth, justice, and indeed history. He said that the holocaust was a sham and there is proof of millions stacked in holocaust survivors accounts to state their misery during the nazi rule. Norman finkelstein at that time professor of political theory, city university of new york, hunter college published a book, the holocaust industry, which criticised the financial motives of those behind the then current exaggerated publicity campaign promoting holocaust history and the use to which it was being put to extort money from a variety of wealthy. Dec 31, 2011 finkelsteins website is full of casual and nonsensical references to jews as nazis. Jewish american historian norman finkelstein argues in his explosive new book, the holocaust industry.
The holocaust industry norman finkelstein vostfr youtube. Verso, 2003 if youre like me and have been through the american education system, you as a child may have never learned a word of greek or latin, the history of the bible or been assigned to. Norman finkelstein makes an astonishing admission boulder. Even if the holocaust were unique, what difference it make. Mar 07, 2007 norman finkelstein is the son of holocaust survivors.
Finkelsteins website is full of casual and nonsensical references to jews as nazis. Full text of finkelstein, norman g holocaust industry, the. The holocaust industry is a serious milestone in the shoah narrative and it will continue to act as a bulwark against revisionism. Einkelstein and ruth bettina birn, a nation on trial. Finkelsteins work provides uncomfortable truths for some when combined with his own unique familial insight into a place in history where many fear to venture. Norman finkelstein explains holocaust crying incident. Aug 17, 2000 finkelstein s work provides uncomfortable truths for some when combined with his own unique familial insight into a place in history where many fear to venture. He also a well known advocate of hezbolah, a shiite islamic militant group and political party based in lebanon. Reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering by norman g. The holocaust industry has nothing to do with the nazi holocaust. Finkelstein s book on before the book was even available to the american public july 19. Norman finkelstein, son of a holocaust survivor, is a fierce and controversial critic of israeli policy, especially toward palestinians. Btw the rest of this page is also terrible, but this quote in particular caught my eye. May 17, 2016 norman finkelsteins the holocaust industry and the fight to make all suffering count.
Norman finkelstein, who used to promptly dismiss deniers as inconsequential idiots, has now become a denier himself. The holocaust industry, however, deals with a different subject. Liberal professor norman finkelstein wrote the holocaust industry to bring to the worlds attention the exploitation of jewish suffering in world war ii. American radical is the probing, definitive documentary about jewishamerican political scientist norman finkelstein. He is also a professor, a political scientist, an activist, a professor and an author. April 2000 new york city footnotes 1 in this text, nazi holocaust signals the actual historical event, the holocaust its ideological representation. The origins of the arabjewish conflict over palestine. Norman finkelsteins the holocaust industry and the fight. Reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering is a 2000 book by norman finkelstein, in which the author argues that the american. Finkelstein talks naz shah mp, ken livingstone, and the labour antisemitism controversy.
Norman finkelsteins the holocaust industry and the. Finkelstein, whose parents were holocaust survivors, tells scheer during their conversation that he purposely used martyrdom in his new books title, as his parents invoked the same term. Norman gary finkelstein is an american political scientist, activist, professor, and author. This is great news in itself, but it gets even better. Read the fulltext online edition of the holocaust industry. In the pages that follow, i will argue that the holocaust is an ideological representation of the nazi holocaust. According to finkelstein, this holocaust industry has corrupted jewish culture and the. Norman finkelstein dear sir, i recently found a holocaust comparison through photographs under the provocative some would say insulting title of deutschland uber alles and the request to please forward, on your website, at the following address. The holocaust industry, norman finkelstein holocaust awareness, the israeli writer boas evron observes, is actually an official, propagandistic indoctrination, a churning out of slogans and a false view of the world, the real aim of which is not at all an understanding of the past, but a manipulation of the present.
227 41 913 777 418 885 1331 543 1402 962 1010 535 629 365 745 1462 1408 243 1328 409 685 685 1517 584 1423 1271 1144 956 646 1454 1253 705 58 780 188 413 122 1454 109 1237